Comments on: What Is Flow? https://www.allaboutlean.com/what-is-flow/ Organize your Industry! Fri, 14 Apr 2023 14:22:59 +0000 hourly 1 By: Helena Melchiori https://www.allaboutlean.com/what-is-flow/#comment-91982 Mon, 03 Oct 2022 21:04:53 +0000 https://www.allaboutlean.com/?p=28025#comment-91982 This was a fascinating post. It was interesting how you said flow was more of a philosophy than a metric. The amount of value-added activities within the flow is the metric that is important to look at where process improvement is needed. I liked how you also included how continuous improvement for process flow is necessary not only to become better but also not to become worse. This is also how businesses can stay competitive within industries because if they aren’t progressing they are degressing.

]]>
By: Jay Bitsack https://www.allaboutlean.com/what-is-flow/#comment-84029 Wed, 27 Jul 2022 15:02:58 +0000 https://www.allaboutlean.com/?p=28025#comment-84029 Hi Chris,

Yes, asking “what is flow” is an important question that’s worthwhile addressing. However, like so many aspects related to the principles, practices, and concepts of TRUE LEAN THINKING AND BEHAVING (ala the combination of TPS/Toyota WAY), the CONTEXT in which any question about those practices, practices, and concepts is being asked and answered is even more important. Without a specified CONTEXT, the meaning being conveyed is often incomplete and potentially misleading. More specifically, whenever these sorts of questions are approached from a deterministic or reductionist POV, what’s often not conveyed is the relationships (i.e., interactions and interdependencies) that exist between the topic of interest (e.g., process FLOW) and ALL the other critical elements of a SYSTEM that need to be taken into consideration.

That said, this blog posting on the topic of “what is flow” seems to be neglecting the bigger (i.e.,more HOLISTIC/SYSTEMIC) CONTEXT in which “flow” related issues can and do occur. More specifically, “what is flow” and “why it is such a critical element in an overall production SYSTEM” is very closely related/tied to and integrated with the other critical elements comprising the OVERALL SYSTEM. And those other elements characteristically take the form of: 1) what constitutes VALUE (as perceived by customers/consumers), 2) WHAT IS THE PROCESS FOR CREATING AND DELIVERING VALUE (while at the same time generating as little waste as possible in the process), 3) what does FLOW have to do with maximizing the value being added and minimizing the waste, 4) how does flow relate to customer/consumer DEMAND and its variability, and 5) why is there a need for CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT/PERFECTION (aka ON-GOING PROBLEM-SOLVING) related to that process flow.

Without addressing these other essential HOLISTIC/SYSTEMIC considerations and thereby limiting one’s answer to a mere/simply technical description of the key characteristics of FLOW by itself carries the strong potential for conveying/promoting a reductionistic mindset; one which is antithetical to the practice of TRUE LEAN THINKING AND BEHAVING.

Bottom line: Yes, excessive inventory levels are problematic to an efficient and effective process flow. But, more importantly, ensuring that VALUE is being maximized and delivered in line with customer/consumer needs and expectations encompasses a wider range of TRUE LEAN THINKING AND BEHAVING capabilities that, if not recognized and addressed, will likely impede the pursuit and realization of world class operational (i.e., systemic) excellence.

]]>
By: Rob van Stekelenborg https://www.allaboutlean.com/what-is-flow/#comment-83957 Tue, 26 Jul 2022 11:29:10 +0000 https://www.allaboutlean.com/?p=28025#comment-83957 Hi Chris,
A topic that has always interested me a lot. I agree partially that it is philosophical. I do think, however, that it ís important to understand also what is more exactly meant when speaking of “flow”. As a clear definition helps identify obstacles to flow, and -inversely- measures to improve flow. I also think it is important as so many “methods” claim to be improving flow, or claim to be better at it than other approaches (just think of DBR, S-DBR, JIT, DDMRP, MRP, …). When working as SC director at Valeo, my single strategy slide only said “create flow” and sites were in need of a better understanding of what exactly it meant. I was in need of a “yardstick” to measure flow that aligned with the philosophical intent of the word “flow” in a process context.
It was the reason why I further developed this topic in three blog posts in 2017:
https://thejitcompany.com/perfect-flow-1/
https://thejitcompany.com/perfect-flow-2/
https://thejitcompany.com/perfect-flow-3/
Look forward to your feedback on these posts.

]]>